kikipeepers asked

Was the decision to stop Nicholas Noel's graduation speech a violation of First Amendment rights?

GRAND RAPIDS, Mich. — School officials pulled the plug on a senior class president’s commencement speech shortly after he referred to his high school as a prison. They also refused to give Nicholas Noel his diploma during his speech May 19 to fellow graduates of Grand Rapids Union High School. The school said he will receive it later. As 1,000 people watched the ceremony held at Grand Rapids Community College’s Ford Fieldhouse, the power to Noel’s microphone was cut off immediately after he made the remark, four sentences into his speech. Noel, who plans to attend Grand Valley State University in the fall, said he described the high school as “the Union High prison system” because students were expected to act alike. The message of his speech was that high school paints for students “a picture of life that is incomplete,” he said. He said the rest of his speech would have been positive had he been allowed to complete it. A copy of his written speech, however, went on to call the school a “foul institution” and a “horribly irresponsible and depraved place to learn these life lessons...”

1,165 answers · 0 comments