Question Who's Online | Find Members | Private Messages
My Journal
Answer Questions | Question Comments | My Questions | Favorites | +Add Question

All | Games | Funny | Entertainment | Quizzes | Weird | Tech | People | Arts/Lit | News | Science | Sports | Places | Misc

874 hits Rate me! Share Favorite | Flag 16 years ago by KikiPeepers

Is flawed logic still logic?

Put This Question on Your Page (MySpace, Livejournal, Blog, etc)
[Preview] EMBED CODE:

Bottom Last Post

16 yrs ago - Saturday 5/6/06 - 11:38:53 PM EST (GMT-5)
Flawed logic is an oxymoron, what you're talking about is illogical logic, but logic itself doesn't have to be logical.

For instance, the classical statement:
If the grass is green, god exists
Grass is green
Therefore, god exists

Is perfect logic, but obviously flawed. Logic is not supposed to be unflawed.

16 yrs ago - Wednesday 5/10/06 - 2:20:45 PM EST (GMT-5)
Interesting gender gap here.
16 yrs ago - Wednesday 5/10/06 - 3:52:53 PM EST (GMT-5)
It's distorted logic in the thinker who believes it, yes.
16 yrs ago - Wednesday 5/10/06 - 5:32:50 PM EST (GMT-5)
I think Trips is right in what he said, if I understood him correctly. The "green grass" syllogism is logically valid, though false, because its first premise is false (where logic dictates that a logically valid argument with true premises cannot have a false conclusion). Conversely, true premises can lead to a false conclusion if the logical form is invalid. Logic is detached from the actual truth values of an argument's premises.

Still, it's hard to know what the question is driving at. Incorrect use of logic, such as in the second picture, is obviously "not logical". However, there has been some exploration of "paraconsistent" logics which, with a common sense approach to logic, would be "flawed". Paraconsistent logics abandon certain intuitively undeniable axioms of logic and inference; consequently, the term "flawed" may betray a certain logical bias.

16 yrs ago - Wednesday 5/10/06 - 5:33:09 PM EST (GMT-5)
Some of these have come about through consideration of paradoxes, which relate to the earlier part of the first post. Paradoxes are instances in which (apparently) true premises lead by (apparently) valid reasoning to clearly false conclusions. Dialetheias (true contradictions) entail some sort of paraconsistent logic, and one motivation to embrace dialetheias has arisen out of efforts to resolve paradoxes by modifying the inferences and axioms of logic itself to render them non-problematic.
16 yrs ago - Wednesday 5/10/06 - 5:54:57 PM EST (GMT-5)
Well, way to completely kill off the debate before it even started.
15 yrs ago, 10 mos ago - Saturday 7/1/06 - 12:33:07 AM EST (GMT-5)
i guess
15 yrs ago, 10 mos ago - Saturday 7/1/06 - 12:39:25 AM EST (GMT-5)
That appears to be the case.
15 yrs ago, 10 mos ago - Friday 7/7/06 - 3:51:05 PM EST (GMT-5)
Flawed logic is still logic--however, I believe that using a true statement to prove a false statement to be true is immoral, and frankly, nothing more than a very weak and pathetic use of logic.

Also, I believe kyry's explanation may have just accidentally killed Dr. Spock.

15 yrs ago, 9 mos ago - Saturday 7/29/06 - 12:40:26 AM EST (GMT-5)
On 5/10/2006 3:52:54 PM GeekyPenguin wrote:
It's distorted logic in the thinker who believes it, yes.

15 yrs ago, 8 mos ago - Saturday 8/26/06 - 11:21:16 PM EST (GMT-5)
yeah, kyry basically shut everybody down. good job.
15 yrs ago, 8 mos ago - Saturday 8/26/06 - 11:26:12 PM EST (GMT-5)
I think kyry should use examples in his posts.
15 yrs ago, 8 mos ago - Wednesday 9/20/06 - 7:12:39 PM EST (GMT-5)
15 yrs ago, 8 mos ago - Wednesday 9/20/06 - 7:13:59 PM EST (GMT-5)
I think Kyry should stop trying to make my head hurt
15 yrs ago, 4 mos ago - Friday 12/29/06 - 7:07:51 AM EST (GMT-5)
I stopped reading Kyry's post before the end, it was too long, im on christmas holidays, too much writing for me
15 yrs ago, 4 mos ago - Friday 12/29/06 - 11:24:11 AM EST (GMT-5)
Maybe it is, who knows?
15 yrs ago, 3 mos ago - Sunday 2/4/07 - 8:52:44 PM EST (GMT-5)
that picture on the right looks like what they teach in algebra. the most useless subject i have ever been subjected to.
14 yrs ago, 9 mos ago - Tuesday 8/7/07 - 12:27:21 AM EST (GMT-5)
I think so o.o because the word logic is in flawed logic xD

You need to be logged in to post a reply

New to YT? Create a Free Account ~ Have an Account? Log In


10 Most Popular Questions Today
1 What does your money do?

2 Do you live in a home that has been owned by your family for multiple generations?

3 Should this 9-year-old girl be granted an abortion? See story.

4 If you had a genetic disease, would you reproduce?

5 Have you sent a postcard into PostSecret?

6 Would you make love with your clone?

7 Should the clock have been shifted 6 hours when it was designed, so that dawn occurs at approximately 12:00 and each hour corresponds to an hour of daylight?

8 Would you like to know the exact date of your death?

9 Do people become more likeable once they`ve realized their faults?

10 Do you prefer croissants or bagels?

More Questions